Girlxoxo.com

Are the Books As Good As the Covers

I've read all the books on my list of 10 Enticing Book Covers of 2011 - and I thought I would share my thoughts on whether the book was as good - better - or worse than the covers.

Are the Books As Good As the Covers? {Finishing the 2011 List}

Imaginary GirlsBefore I Go to Sleep

Imaginary Girls, Nova Ren Suma. The book is as good as the cover promises!
Ooh - I just loved this book. It kept me guessing as to what was really going on in the story, and although I was left with a few unanswered questions at the end, overall, I loved the book and highly recommend it - and I hope there is a "prequel" (see more of my discussion of the book).

Before I Go to Sleep, S.J. Watson. The book is as good as the cover promises.
Another book that I adored! Actually, the book cover clued me that something wasn't quite right from the beginning - and this book also kept me guessing about what was really going on. It's one of my Favorite Books Read During 2011.

The Magician KingThe Night Circus

The Magician King, Lev Grossman. This is a tough one. The book did deliver a magical story as the cover promised, but I was infuriated with parts of the book - so I'm going to have to say this cover was better than the book. {see more of my discussion}.

The Night Circus, Erin Morgenstern. The book was as good as the cover promises!
I loved the fantasy and the world that this book created. I was invested in the characters and the outcome of their stories. Such a lovely, well written book and the author, Morgenstern is one of 5 Debut Authors Whose Books I Read and Loved in 2011.

Map of TimeAnna Dressed in Blood

Map of Time, Felix J. Palma. The cover is better than the book.
This book cover certainly promises a time traveling mystery - and it delivers. But it seemed that there were 2 separate stories told in the book - and the first story, the first half of the book, was much better than the 2nd half.

Anna Dressed in Blood, Kendare Blake. The book is just as good as the cover promises.
The girl on the cover is spooky, and the book synopsis promises a riveting mystery - and that's what we got! I loved the plot surprises, the pace of the story is fast moving, and the book is action packed {see more in Weekly Reading with Anna Dressed in Blood and The Alchemist}.

A Monster CallsFull Dark No Stars

A Monster Calls, Patrick Ness. The cover is a bit scarier than the book - but I loved both!
This book should be giving to every young person that is dealing with loss of a friend or family member and should be in every school library. It's well written and very moving. Ness is one of 10 Authors I Read in 2011 That I Want to Read More From in 2012.

Full Dark, No Stars, Stephen King. The book was as good, although not as creepy as the cover.
King does as an excellent job writing in vivid detail to bring the stories to life. I love (well written) short stories, and I love Stephen King.

KindredAcross the Universe

Kindred, Octavia E. Butler. The book is better than the cover!
Although the cover does have a ghost like quality, the story is so much more complex than than the cover portrays. And the book made me hunger for more from Butler! She's another of the 10 Authors I Read in 2011 That I Want to Read More From in 2012.

Across the Universe, Beth Revis. The book is better than the cover
There was much more to the book than a romance, which is what the cover implies is the main theme to the story - and although I love the cover - I'm so thrilled that the book was even better. The 2nd book, A Million Suns, came out in January - see January Book Release Excitement.

Have you read any of these books - what do you think - was the cover better or worse than the book?
- (Inspired by The Broke & Bookish Top 10 Tuesday)

 

-: Comments :-

La Toya | January 24, 2012 9:38 AM | Reply

Wow you have tougher skin than me! I thought Full Dark No Stars was super duper scary!! And I agree, A Monster Calls wasn't as scary as the cover but a fantastic read.

I love the cover for The Magician King! Too bad it didn't match up :-/

Li @ rulethewaves.net | January 24, 2012 9:41 AM | Reply

Great list, those covers are really stunning! I totally agree re: The Night Circus and Before I Go To Sleep. I wished the North American cover of The Magician King was that one, that one is far prettier than the one I've been seeing in the bookstore (still debating whether to check it out tbh).

Here's my TTT for this week! =)

Andi (Estella's Revenge) | January 24, 2012 11:17 AM | Reply

Intriguing idea for a post!! I'm glad most of the books were as good or even better than the cover. I think I want to read darn near all of these!

Tammy | January 24, 2012 1:24 PM | Reply

Hi Tanya, great top ten idea! I'm going to have to try that one...so sorry to say Octavia E. Butler passed away a couple of years ago. She is/was an amazing writer.

Also, must put in my two cents on The Magician King. For me, DEADLY boring and I only got through the first 50 pages before giving up. Totally agree with you on The Night Circus.

Tanya Patrice replied to comment from Tammy | January 24, 2012 1:26 PM | Reply

Hey Tammy - yup - The Magician King wasn't a favorite read of mine - it was okay. I should have said that I want to read more of Butler's books since she passed away and I discovered her way too late!

fishgirl182 | January 24, 2012 1:33 PM | Reply

this is a great topic. i am always picking up books based on covers. i just picked up a monster calls and it looks really scary. thanks for sharing!

Karis (YA Litwit) | January 24, 2012 1:34 PM | Reply

Great list! I thought The Night Circus was WAY better than the cover, as was Anna Dressed In Blood. I agree that the cover of Across the Universe didn't hold a candle to the story, but it's gorgeous nonetheless!

Check out my Top Ten Books I Think Should Be Read/Discussed in EVERY High School!

The Bookworm Hun | January 24, 2012 2:05 PM | Reply

I agree with everyone: truly a great topic! The only book I've read on the list is Kindred. We studied it in a course on imperialism in literature, but I re-read it again last year and, though there are moments where I don't think the story's told in as sophisticated a way as it could have been, I love the idea and I love the tale. For me, the cover and the book are tied.

I looooove the Imaginary Girls cover. Can't wait to read that one.

Taylor | January 24, 2012 4:54 PM | Reply

wow. I absolutely loved this list. Now i definitely want to pick up imaginary girls.. the cover is just so gorgeous! I am definitely following as I am a BIG fan of lists and you seem to be as well :)

you can check out my list, check out my list... Top Ten Books off My Shelf I am Dying to Read if you want!

nea barabea (@neabarabea) | January 24, 2012 6:28 PM | Reply

I really need to read Anna! It became a must read right now! :) ;)

Zo | January 24, 2012 8:08 PM | Reply

I haven't read any of these yet. I've never seen Imaginary Girls or Anna Dressed in Blood before so I'm glad to see that they're as good as the covers! They look very intriguing!

Laura @ The Traveling Owl | January 24, 2012 11:26 PM | Reply

Such a cute idea.

I thought that the Night Circus was just as good as the cover, and I totally agree about Across the Universe. I was wary until I read it. I need to start on the sequel soon.

Laura @ The Traveling Owl

Vasilly | January 25, 2012 4:49 PM | Reply

I've read similar thoughts about The Map of Time. I haven't read Kindred yet but it could definitely use a better cover.

Truly Bookish | January 26, 2012 9:37 AM | Reply

Thanks for stopping by my blog and I love yours. This is such a great feature. I def agree with you about Across the Universe and Anna Dressed in Blood - the two books on this list that I read. BTW, I read your bio and I'm originally from Jamaica as well :-)
NC
Truly Bookish

Lady Jaye | January 27, 2012 7:33 AM | Reply

I have Kindred in my suitcase, waiting for me to pick up. I will move it up on my tbr.

What Say You?!




Warning: include(/home/gyrl/public_html/sidebar.php) [function.include]: failed to open stream: No such file or directory in /home/gyrl/public_html/books/are-the-books-as-good-as-the-covers-finishing-the-list.php on line 623

Warning: include() [function.include]: Failed opening '/home/gyrl/public_html/sidebar.php' for inclusion (include_path='.:/usr/lib/php:/usr/local/lib/php') in /home/gyrl/public_html/books/are-the-books-as-good-as-the-covers-finishing-the-list.php on line 623

 

=: Home | About | Archives | Subscribe (RSS) :=