Girlxoxo.com

Book Chat

Weekly Book Chat - From Books to Movies

From TGIF Reads
Q. Book to Movie: Which book turn movie do you feel did the best adaptation? What about the worst?
Harry Potter and the Deathly HallowsCall me crazy but I don't like to read a book AND watch the movie - I prefer one or the other. That said, the worst, is that 2nd to last Harry Potter movie - Harry Potter and The Deathly Hallows (Pt. 1). I felt it could have been eliminated totally and it wouldn't have made a difference, or at the very least it could have been combined with part 2. A close runner up is the TV series adaptation of The Sword of Truth series by Terry Goodkind (LOVED the books). The tv series, called Legend of the Seeker, ran from 2008 - 2010 and it was utter rubbish - especially the acting.

As for the best adaptation, I'm going with The Bourne Identity, The Bourne Supremacy & The Bourne Ultimatum by Robert Ludlum. The movies, starring Matt Damon, really brought the books to life - action packed & fast paced ... but Luddie (that's my pet name for Robert Ludlum), I'm still peeved that you sold out and let Eric Van Lustbader write 2 more books in this series - straight screenplay-ish style. Not cool Luddie. Not cool!

From Pen to Paper
The Time Travelers WifeQ. Friday Recommends - Pick a book that you've read, and have enjoyed enough to recommend to other readers.
Since we're talking about books with movie adaptations, one of my favorite books is A Time Traveler's Wife, Audrey Niffenegger. No I didn't see the movie - I couldn't - I KNEW I would be moved to tears at the ending, and I just wouldn't be able to handle it. Yes - I'm a bit of a wuss!

Summary: When Henry meets Clare, he is twenty-eight and she is twenty. Henry has never met Clare before; Clare has known Henry since she was six. Impossible but true, because Henry finds himself periodically displaced in time, pulled to moments of emotional gravity from his life, past and future. Henry and Clare's attempts to live normal lives are threatened by a force they can neither prevent nor control, making their passionate love story intensely moving and entirely unforgettable.

Interesting Bookish Stuff Seen Recently

  • Reviews and Reviewing (at The Picky Girl). ... interesting article on review sites like Amazon.com, Goodreads & Shelfari, and why this blogger prefers to get book recommendations from other bloggers or twitter. My opinion - I actually like the rating system combined with a synopsis of a book - but usually for books with many ratings. When it comes to books that aren't well known - I have to go with blogger recommendations.

  • Number Crunching (at Guy with a Moleskin Notebook) - How many books do you typically read in a year? Like this Guy, I'm not a speed reader and I don't want to be. I'm going back to averaging 1-2 books a week. Anything more than that and I won't remember the details, author or even the name of the main character - a week after I've read the book!

 

-: Comments :-

Kah_cherub | December 9, 2011 8:33 AM | Reply

I haven't read the book or seen the movie, but if it's crying material... maybe I'll get to it soon. LOL

starryeyedjen | December 9, 2011 9:09 AM | Reply

Ah, I loved the HP books AND movies. I came into that series after all the books were out, though, and had already seen several of the movies prior to starting the series.

I haven't read the Bourne series but the movies are awesome. The hubby and I could watch those over and over again...and do. He's even interested in reading the series now, and he is SO not a reader. :)

trish | December 9, 2011 10:46 AM | Reply

I LOVED the Time Travellers Wife -- book version. the movie ... eh. not so much! i should've put that on my list for my TGIF answer!

SaraO @ TheLibrarianReads | December 9, 2011 2:33 PM | Reply

Do not hurt me...but I haven't finished the Harry Potter movies! *gasp* I read all the books as soon as they came out, but the movies were pushed a bit to the wayside. I was happy with them (till I stopped watching) but haven't finished the series. I have noticed a few people listing it as a fail. Guess I'll just have to sit down one day and finally watch!

Anna @ YA in the Second City | December 10, 2011 12:38 AM | Reply

Oh, I really liked HP7.1—even (especially?) the scene with Harry and Hermione dancing to Nick Cave & the Bad Seeds, which I know didn't go over so well with most viewers. HP7.2 is clearly superior, but I think that together, they're the strongest adaptation of a Harry Potter book since Prisoner of Azkaban. The screenplay and direction took more liberties with the specifics of the story, allowing the movie to become something independent, rather than the straight retellings of most of the other movies.

Anyway. I'm absolutely not a speed reader. So far, I'm on pace to read 52 books this year. Frankly, I'm not sure I'd want to read many more than that. So often one book begins to fade if I pick another too soon after; I don't like to rush myself.

What Say You?!



About {Me}

Hi! You have reached the internet experiment station of Tanya Patrice, editor of food product reviews for i{ate}A{pie}.net and creator of workout music playlists for intheGym.net. Here is where the bookish side of me resides - I am an ecclectic reader which means you'll see many different genres represented - from young adult novels to speculative fiction ... more »

subscribe by RSS subscribe by email find me on pinterest find me on twitter find me on goodreads

Recently {Written}

Girlxoxo Beginnings, Nebula Awards Predictions And May Library Loot {3}
10 Things Today {The May 2012 Edition}
Weekly Reading With The Girl of Fire and Thorns
The Sunday Best Link Party {2}
Character Assassin & May Library Loot {2}
{Bloggers Recommend} Unforgettable Memoirs
I Eat Short Stories {Finishing the 2011 List}

-: Archives :-

Books Read {Recently}

The Girl of Fire and Thorns (Book) Chime (Book) Ultraviolet (Book) The Replacement (Book) Among Others Everybody Sees the Ants The Night Strangers Akata Witch Daughter of Smoke and Bone

-: Books Read in 2012 :-


 

Book Lists {Recent}

I Eat Short Stories {Finishing the 2011 List} May Book Release Excitement 10 Must See Book To Movie Adaptations in 2012 10 Lessons Learned From The Last 10 Books Read in 2012 ( Part 2) Reading the 2011 Nebula Awards Nominees {2012 Reading List}

-: More Book Lists :-

Challenges {Hosting}

Reading the Award Winners Challenge
{Sign Up | Link Reviews}
2014 Winter Olympics Reading Challenge
{Sign Up | Link Reviews}
 

Challenges {Doing}

2012 Reading Challenges

Book Awards {Calendar}

Book Awards Calendar

 

Most Popular {Entries}

10 Books On My Reading List for Spring 2012 (35)
10 Hot Dystopian Novels {on my 2012 Reading List} (28)
10 Must See Book To Movie Adaptations in 2012 (24)
10 Tips on Book Blogging That Will Help You Win Friends & Influence People (23)
10 Books I Would Read If I Had An Entire Day To Myself {The Book Series Update Edition} (22)
10 Books to Shake Things Up at Your Boring Book Club {The 2011 Edition} (22)

 

=: Home | About | Archives | Subscribe (RSS) :=